No offense but I think this system is too much work for people to actually use. If it were possible to have simple up and down arrows with a post rating (Like Reddit or Gameriot.) it would probably get some more use :P.
I believe that another system should be added to the website where you can +/- Rep people on the forums. With this addition, people can rep depending if they find comments left by the poster helpful or just trolling and this can ultimately assist in keeping the quality of the information on this site up to the highest degree.
With more helpful information to the website, that will bring in more frequent visits to the website because people find it more useful to log in and read through the forums and it can also add in a fun little system that regular posters can generally enjoy by wanting to gain reputation points and thus causing them to make enjoyable or informative posts.
Currently most people just look through a person's previous gladiator history title but as many people know, that doesn't mean a lot much of the time. With a reputation system, when you read someone with a high reputation value, you can almost be guaranteed that you will be reading advice or information worthwhile of your time.
TLDR: Add in reputation system which I think will increase the quality of this site.