I'll agree to the point where the comp is strong and baddiefriendly, but its not the "undefeatable r1 supermega dampening comp" you make it out to be. I dont mind facing this on my other toons, infact I rather face it than the overlords of rmd/turbo/godcomp
rofl you have to be shitting me
Let's put it this way, there's a 1-5 grading scale which determines comp's strength for Glad+ viability in game's meta ( at the time or now ).
5 : requires 3 Gladiator+ quality players to run, who need to have synergy together, need to have tactics sorted out on what to do versus certain compositions, et cetera et cetera. WoTLK RMP is a solid example of this grade, WoTLK MLD is there as well ( to everyone who doesn't agree - bitch fucking please, I don't think more than 5 MLD's got gladiator in EU in S8 ). There are no MoP or WoD comps that even approach this threshold.
4 : requires at least Glad quality players to run, some synergy is needed and some tactics are needed, but otherwise an easy sail for a title. Prime examples being stuff like S8 RLS, WoTLK/Cataclysm RPS, S8 WLD. I have no clue if I'd put any WoD comp here as well.
3 : straightforward stuff, requires decent players who just need a bit of practice together to get stuff rolling, but otherwise comp is so straightforward that no heavy thinking about it is required. Examples are stuff like S6/S9 TSG, S11 legendary RLS, WoD Junglecleave, WoD Turbocleave, WoD RMD, WoD Godcomp, etc.
2 : braindead stuff, aka doesn't require good players at all or anything special outside of players except a bit of awareness, tiny bit of practice and a pulse, stuff like S16 Nessper's RLD, S8 beastcleave and S11 ret rogue hunter are prime examples of this tier
1 : afk tier. Aka, it doesn't require out of you ANYTHING except rotating your basic pve rotation and following a ONE SENTENCE GUIDE. S3 rogue/disc priest/resto druid, TBC warlock/hunter/druid ( draincomp, aka get into arena, and spam viper sting/drain mana until enemy team is OOM ), S8 protret paladin/resto shaman/dics priest, S8 warrior/disc priest/holy paladin, S16 rogue/disc/holy.
Literally 99% of WoD comps are either #2 or #3, dumbing the game to #1 and exclaiming you're having fun is shitting in your own mouth. Although I guess I'd be having fun as well if I was as shit to actually have to play something from #1 or #2 to actually gain rating in WoD.
It's beyond my own fucking understanding how can someone REASON with himself in his own mind that this double healer rogue isn't worse 100x than facing a RMD/Godcomp/Turbo/Jungle. Those comps introduced the art of boredom in WoD, your shit is their shit amplified tenfold. You sit on a fucking healer and that's your entire strategy, win or lose, you could fucking have honorbuddy play your rogue and nobody would notice it wasn't a human. For all I know, you probably are doing so.