I don't see the argument in this sentence. I mean yeah, warriors could need some rework, but comparing damage loss of a warrior to a rogue? Wtf?
My rogue make 6-7k mutilate hits outside of cd's. Even with wall up you MAYBE make more damage then a rogue the whole time without cd's.
Not that i'm complaining about the low damage, rogues have other adventages.
I don't think you can compare this like that. Have you ever watched games of highraited rogues that are being trained from a hunter team or kited + focused from casterteams?
They often have under 1-1,5 Million damage after 2-3 min games, just because they are leatherwearer and have to hug the pillars + spam feint against any possible incoming stun. Of course the damage of a rogue with cd's is quite nice, and we have things like vanish, but we also have leather armor and have not the opportunity to use shield or endless defstance against incoming stuns.
I see your point that warriors need to be reworked. But i think the defensive is not the problem. They just could need another damage cd on a shorter cd apart from 3 mins Avatar. (Something like bladestorm in wotlk)