negative, worst case s5 was bad other 3 were good
you could still beat dk's in s5 too. you couldn't beat shatterplay in s12 unless your warrior got a 5 stack taste for blood proc
You could beat Shatterplay as other comps too, even after TFB was nerfed/redesigned. This is not opinion, this is a fact.
I swear you are literally the only person I have ever met to say that WotLK PvP was good apart from S8. Every other guy with whom I've spoken (I am not talking about 1-2 people, but like 10+ more) seems to curse every other season that wasn't specifically "Wrathful".
Edited by Hollowinside, 25 February 2017 - 10:49 PM.