Soulfrost vs +40 spell damage

[Ultimecia]

So pretty soon I'm gonna be replacing my crappy blue 1h with the S3 version and was wondering what you guys thought would be the best enchant to have on it.

Basically soulfrost is an extra 14 shadow damage while sacrificing 40 fire damage. Personally although I use primarily shadow spells in the arena I still find myself using a few fire spells and was leaning towards 40 spell damage again, been told that soulfrost is more of a PvE enchant.

Anyway just wanted some second opinions, actually getting the materials and enchanting done isn't really an issue once I've picked which one to get.

[buena]

You could make an argument either way but the real conclusion is that it doesn't make much difference. And soulfrost is freaking expensive.

[Phiers]

if you're not destro, soulfrost.

40 shadow and 40 fire vs 54 shadow means that you need to do 1/4th or more of your damage in fire for it to equal out the extra shadow dmg.

[kyoshi]

if you're not destro, soulfrost.

40 shadow and 40 fire vs 54 shadow means that you need to do 1/4th or more of your damage in fire for it to equal out the extra shadow dmg.
i raid as shadow destro. soulfrost isnt that bad lol. i use it on my weapon. makes all my spells that much more potent. 14 shadowpower might not be alot, but it adds up over time. i have had long long matches

[Cantis]

And soulfrost is freaking expensive.

[Shadowborne]

Spellsurge

[Cantis]

Spellsurge
Why? We're talking about 2v2 right? I've heard that spellsurge is only worth it in 5v5

[Erosion]

Spellsurge
Why? We're talking about 2v2 right? I've heard that spellsurge is only worth it in 5v5

Shadowbourne prefers to bore his opponents to death. :lol:

In seriousness though, if you're playing hardcore outlast like Shadowbourne does spellsurge is worth it in 2v2.

[Shadowborne]

Why? We're talking about 2v2 right? I've heard that spellsurge is only worth it in 5v5

Dual spellsurge is an extra 16 mp/5 for your healer. In a game of outlast why would you not focus on your teams weakness which is your healers mana pool.